38 Best Copycat Recipes from the Southern Living Archives – Southern Living

Raise your hand if you’ve ever heard some iteration of the statement: “We’re not going out to eat; we have food here.” If you’re not raising your hand, you’re either lying or very rich. Even as adults, it can be difficult to eat the kale salad in your fridge when you’re fighting an overwhelming craving for your favorite local pizza spot. With this list of our best restaurant copycat recipes, though, “we have food here” is the best news a kid (or parent) can get. Whether you have a hankering for the fried goodness of a Bloomin’ Onion or the sweet comfort of a Pop Tart in the morning, we have copycat recipes you’ll love. With nostalgic copycat recipes like homemade Bomb Pops and Cookie Cake, little ones will want to get involved in cooking up their favorite treats with you. As someone who had carryout Thai food last night, I can’t say I always subscribe to the “we have food here” mindset, but these incredible restaurant copycat recipes will have me and you both eating in more often.
Recipe: Copycat Chick-fil-A Chicken Minis
We've all had a Chick-fil-A breakfast craving on a Sunday morning when they're closed. Instead of being disappointed, try this homemade recipe from Test Kitchen pro and Hey Y'all host Ivy Odom.
Recipe: Homemade Pop Tarts
We gave your favorite breakfast pastry from childhood a grown-up (but still oh-so-sweet) makeover in this from-scratch recipe. This would be a fun recipe to get the kids or grandkids involved in baking.
Recipe: Air Fryer Bloomin’ Onion
Is there anything the air fryer can't do? It just might be a miracle to be able to enjoy this famous appetizer at home without a greasy mess. Don't skip making the homemade sauce, y'all.
Recipe: Homemade Moon Pies
The Chattanooga brand has been serving up these treats for more than 100 years, but Southerners mostly recognize them from Mardi Gras, where they're often thrown to crowds in parades. Watch Test Kitchen pro and Hey Y'all host Ivy Odom try her hand at recreating the chocolate Moon Pie flavor at the recipe link.
Recipe: Mini Potato Skins
This TGI Fridays appetizer is so popular, they started selling it in the frozen section of the grocery store. But don't go store-bought without trying our homemade version first. We promise it will be worth it.
Recipe: Lemon Loaf Cake
Don't turn into that drive thru! This week, try our homemade iced lemon loaf cake. It's the perfect companion to your morning coffee, and one reviewer even remarked that, "I think its [sic] better than S******ks (coffee chain) lemon loaf cake that everyone raves about."
Recipe: Bang Bang Shrimp
Bonefish Grill made these sweet-and-spicy shrimp famous as an appetizer, but there are countless ways to enjoy them at home with our copycat recipe. Put them in lettuce wraps, tacos, or sandwiches, too.
Recipe: Carrot & Raisin Salad
We miss Chick-fil-A’s Carrot & Raisin Salad. So much so that we even wrote a plea begging them to bring it back. And even though they didn’t put it back on the menu, they did share the recipe for it online, for which we’re grateful.
Recipe: Hashbrown Casserole
You won't attend a Southern potluck that doesn't have hashbrown casserole on the sideboard. Both our recipe and Cracker Barrel's contain the usual suspects, but ours is topped with a crunchy cornflake cereal topping that we can't resist.
Recipe: Spicy Sausage-and-Cheddar Kolaches Recipe
Of all the Southern food you can find at Texas-favorite road trip stop Buc-ee’s, kolaches are up there on our list of favorites. If you forget to grab one on your next trip to Buc-ee’s, try making them at home with coffee and fruit salad for a delicious weekend brunch.
Recipe: Broccoli-Cheddar Soup

It might seem easier to run to Panera to pick up a bowl of warm Broccoli-Cheddar Soup, but this 30-minute recipe will be ready even quicker than that. Serve in a Toasted Bread Bowl for the ultimate Panera-at-home experience.
Recipe: Instant Pot Egg Bites
The secret to perfectly cooked egg bites with a soft center is, of course, your do-it-all Instant Pot. Our version of this protein-packed breakfast includes bacon, broccoli, and Cheddar cheese, but you can swap those out for whatever fillings you have on hand.
Recipe: Homemade Little Debbie Christmas Tree Cakes
Looking for a fun way to keep the kids or grandkids occupied while they're out of school for the holidays? This baking challenge should do the trick! Layers of soft sponge cake and Swiss meringue buttercream knock Little Debbie's version out of the park (no offense, Deb).
Recipe: Homemade Berry Pop Tarts
Leave it to Test Kitchen pro and Hey Y'all host Ivy Odom to create this adorable copycat version of the berry Pop Tarts you remember from school mornings. She opted for assorted sprinkles that fit a Valentine's Day theme, but you can include a streak or two of blue icing to mimic the store-bought version.
Recipe: BBQ Chicken Pizza
California Pizza Kitchen's Original BBQ Chicken Pizza has been on their menu since 1985. There's a reason it's been around so long—it's just that tasty. Our iteration makes for a family-fun night at home.
Recipe: Chocolate Chip Cookie Cake
Since 1977, the arrival of a Great American Cookies Cookie Cake has automatically been a sure sign of a celebration. Cement your status as a party starter with our homemade version.
Recipe: Spinach-Artichoke Dip
Houston's menu is full of fancy items like sushi and elegant entrées, but regulars know that classic, comforting Spinach & Artichoke Dip is a must-try appetizer at the restaurant. Our version will keep party guests coming back until the whole dish is scraped clean.
Recipe: Copycat Starbucks Bistro Boxes
When you're on a road trip, Starbucks Protein Boxes are often a saving grace for drivers who want something lighter than burgers and fries. These copycat recipes make great work snacks or after-school bites for kids, pre-portioned and ready to go.
Recipe: Toasted Bread Bowls
It's so much easier to recreate your Panera order than you thought. Simply buy bread rounds from your local bakery, cut the tops and scoop the centers, and toast. Our secret to making them even more delicious than takeout? A sprinkling of Parmesan cheese.
Recipe: Red, White, and Blue Popsicles
Can't you just hear the ice cream truck's song coming down your street? Relive the wonder of Southern childhood summers with homemade Bomb Pops at home. Mamas will love that our version is made with fresh strawberries and blueberries and no food dye.
Recipe: Shrimp Alfredo
You don’t have to go out to eat to indulge in a creamy, comforting Alfredo pasta dish. You don’t even have to buy a jar of sauce at the store. This lightened-up, elevated recipe will raise your bar for shrimp Alfredo.
Recipe: Homemade Turtles
These delightful clusters of caramel, pecans, and chocolate make wonderful food gifts during the holidays. While your friends will be wowed with the homemade treats, these candies are actually pretty easy to master, so they just might turn into a Christmas tradition for you.
Recipe: The Masters Egg Salad Sandwiches
Augusta National is home to one of the world’s most famous golf tournaments, the Masters. Perhaps even more well-known than some of the golfers who play in it are the unique Masters traditions. Though the $1.50 pimiento cheese sandwiches get the spotlight, the egg salad sandwiches are the real favorite of regulars.
Recipe: Hurry-Up Homemade Crescent Rolls
Even though we're huge proponents for making most things from scratch, there are plenty of store-bought shortcuts even our Test Kitchen pros use on the regular. It's safe to say we probably all have a can of Pillsbury Crescent Rolls in our freezers right now. But for the holidays or a special occasion, try our easy homemade version that will impress your guests.
Recipe: Old-Fashioned Pecan Logs
The original Stuckey’s Pecan Logs were homemade by Mrs. Stuckey herself back in the 1930s. Recreate this Southern go-to road trip snack at home with our recipe that one five star reviewer wrote: “Wonderful recipe! A new Christmas favorite for sure!”
Recipe: Peach Milkshake
Each summer, Chick-fil-A fans eagerly await the moment when the news will break that the chain's beloved peach milkshake is back on the menu for a limited time. Instead of being on Chick-fil-A's timeline, make one yourself with this easy recipe.
Recipe: Homemade Fried Chicken Sandwich
The “Chicken Sandwich War” of 2019 was so viral and inescapable, it got its own Wikipedia page. Since the hype has slowed considerably in the past few years, why not throw your own version of the fried chicken sandwich in the ring with our recipe?
Recipe: Homemade Peppermint Patties
YORK Peppermint Patties have been in the picture since 1940, and we're bringing that refreshing taste to your kitchen with this homemade recipe. For a festive holiday look, we topped our version with crushed peppermints.
Recipe: Honey BBQ Chicken Wings
Honey BBQ is one of the wing chain's most popular sauce flavors among dozens. Our homemade sauce will convince you to leave the bottle on the store shelf and forget that online order to BWW.
Recipe: New Orleans Beignets
This simple and surprisingly easy beignet recipe will give you a delicious taste of New Orleans. However, we can't promise you the French Quarter atmosphere to go along with it.
Recipe: Sweet Potato Soufflé
This New Orleans-founded steak house is famous, of course, for its steaks. But a steak is nothing without some delicious sides to complement it, as any Southerner who's ever been to a potluck knows. Like Ruth's Chris fan-favorite sweet potato casserole, our Sweet Potato Soufflé is topped with an irresistibly crumbly and sweet topping that contains brown sugar and pecans.
Recipe: Homemade Cherry Limeade
The drive-in restaurant is famous for its roller-blade clad staff, cool drinks, and corndogs. This recipe from Nashville entertainer Katie Jacobs is her go-to for the annual Fourth of July Party. If you’re preparing it for an adults-only party, try our Vodka Cherry Limeade on for size.
Recipe: Cranberry Chicken Salad
Chicken salad has long been a Southern favorite for quick, delicious lunches, and Stacy Brown turned that concept into a Southern chain of fast-casual restaurants called Chicken Salad Chick. Her menu has plenty of sweet and savory options for you to get your chicken salad fix, and this Southern Living recipe is most like the Cranberry Kelli variety.
Recipe: Red Velvet Cheesecake-Vanilla Cake with Cream Cheese Frosting
These beauties combine layers of red velvet cheesecake and white cake for a stunning presentation that's ready for a holiday. Both The Cheesecake Factory's version and ours are encased in a classic cream cheese icing.
Recipe: Easy Boarding House Meatloaf
Just like Cracker Barrel's meatloaf recipe, ours includes tomatoes, onions, and green peppers. However, if we do say so ourselves, our meatloaf sauce on top is truly something special.
Recipe: Classic Birthday Cake
Funfetti products are some of the most nostalgic options on the baking aisle, but y'all know Mama won't bake with a boxed mix. This homemade version of a Funfetti cake will make any occasion feel like a party.
Recipe: Chick-fil-A Cole Slaw
Among the discontinued Chick-fil-A items we wish they’d bring back is the chicken restaurant’s beloved cole slaw. Luckily, Chick-fil-A shared their real recipe, so you can relive the magic at home.
Recipe: Fried Pickle Chips
Fried pickles were once a limited-time offering on Zaxby’s menu, but fans are rejoicing that the fast food chain has officially added them to the menu full time. If we’re being honest, though, our Roundhouse Kick Sauce is so much better with them.
When you visit the site, Dotdash Meredith and its partners may store or retrieve information on your browser, mostly in the form of cookies. Cookies collect information about your preferences and your devices and are used to make the site work as you expect it to, to understand how you interact with the site, and to show advertisements that are targeted to your interests. You can find out more about our use, change your default settings, and withdraw your consent at any time with effect for the future by visiting Cookies Settings, which can also be found in the footer of the site.


About Merisa

Check Also

10 Best Recipes With Beef Broth – Insanely Good – Insanely Good Recipes

More results… More results… If you’re looking for mouthwatering ways to use up that leftover …

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *